An agency usually has a folder of lists that went quiet after a campaign ended. The question is whether there is a service in that folder.
See a sample reportWant a diagnosis on your own list? Email caseylangness@gmail.com.
An agency runs a campaign, reports on it, and moves to the next client or the next quarter. The list stays. It was real, it was opted in, and it produced some conversations. Then the campaign ended and the follow-up stopped. That is a normal byproduct of agency work, not a failure.
The same pattern repeats across clients. A campaign ends, a budget moves, a reporting cycle closes, and the export goes into a folder. Multiply that by every client and every year, and the agency is sitting on a large amount of data that nobody has looked at since the last report.
The cleanest first test is the agency's own list: leads from your own site, events, referrals, or a campaign you ran for yourself. You control the consent and the data. You can see the result without asking a client for anything. If the diagnosis is useful on your own list, you have a story you can show.
A client's export belongs to the client. Do not send it to a third party without the client's permission. If the client asks for the diagnosis, the agency can run it or the client can send the export directly. The audit is designed for a CSV the client chooses to share, not a live CRM connection. That boundary protects the agency as much as the client.
The one-page report is not the campaign. It is the reason for the conversation. It tells the client what their old list still holds, what was set aside, and why. The agency can use it to open a reactivation project, or to show a client that the list is not worth working. Both are useful answers.
Send a CSV export, the date range, the offer the leads originally saw if you have it, and any consent or source fields. Do not send CRM credentials. The report comes back with a prioritized list, a quarantine list, and a reconciliation.
The diagnosis is a small fixed-fee item. It can be included in a retainer, sold as a one-off, or used as the first step of a larger reactivation project. Do not price it as a revenue guarantee. It is a diagnostic, not a forecast. The agency can decide whether to bundle it or charge for it separately.
Do not promise a number of meetings. Do not promise that every record is usable. Do not promise that a client's list is compliant just because it is old. Promise a clear read of the data and a documented reason for every decision. That is a smaller promise, and it is one the report can keep.
Run the diagnosis on your own list first. If it holds up, offer it to one client with a clear scope. If the client's list has no recoverable value, say so. That answer protects the relationship and makes the next conversation easier.